Toybox Values

Potion (2017): Uncommon knife in Murder Mystery 2

Potion (2017) is an Uncommon knife in Murder Mystery 2. It comes from 2017 Halloween Box, where the wiki lists 25% for its rarity.
Data checked: Oct 10, 2026
RarityUncommon
TypeKnife
Origin2017 Halloween Box
EventHalloween Event 2017

Boxes that hold it

Box Price Chance of the rarity
2017 Halloween Box 100 Candies 25%

For Common to Legendary the wiki prints one number per rarity on every row of the box, so no per-weapon chance or expected box count is shown.

FAQ

How do I get Potion (2017) in Murder Mystery 2?

Origin of Potion (2017) on the wiki: 2017 Halloween Box. Event: Halloween Event 2017.

What is the chance of Potion (2017) from a box?

Potion (2017), 2017 Halloween Box: 25%. The wiki prints one number for every Uncommon row of the box, so it is the chance of the rarity, not of Potion (2017) alone.

What does one try for Potion (2017) cost?

Potion (2017) comes from 2017 Halloween Box, which costs 100 Candies per box on the wiki.

Also in 2017 Halloween Box: Mummy (2017) · Webs · Zombie Knife (2017) · Phantom (2017)

All weapons · Box odds

Source: Potion (2017) (rev 175970, Feb 28, 2026), 2017 Halloween Box (rev 174405, Dec 31, 2025) · Murder Mystery 2 Wiki (Fandom), CC BY-SA 3.0. Numbers and names restructured into tables; wiki images and prose are not used. Not affiliated with the game's developers or Roblox Corporation. Data checked: Oct 10, 2026.